小粉屋原名:Little Pink House,又名Little Pink House
A small-town nurse named Susette Kelo emerges as the reluctant leader of her working-class neighbors in their struggle to save their homes from political and corporate interests bent on seizing the land and handing it over to Pfizer Corporation. Susette's battle goes all the way to the US Supreme Court and the controversial 5-4 decision in Kelo vs. **** of New London gave gover...
张教授推荐的,今天突然想起来了补标一下。真实故事改编还算不错,就是二元对立太严重,有一些仇视精英,作为电影的话感觉表现手法生硬了些。
在一门大学城市发展课上 教授布置看这一部电影 了解私**利和城市发展之间的关系。拍得很感人
钉子户的故事,美国宪法声称保护公民私有财产不受侵犯,没想到还有这样一条修正案:如果政府是为了“公共需要”征用你的土地那就合法,而且这个公共需要竟然可以是卖地给私企因为他们创造更多税收。听上去很不合理但法律真的就是这样,最高法院的判决也把希望消除得一干二净。个**利?不存在的
***返沪途中,全英文看完。根据真实故事改编,虽然结局拆强人意,但为私权奋斗的过程很精彩。7.5分
对私人产权保护的边界应该在哪里,如**衡私产和公权的关系,连美国如此强调私产的国家都没达成一致。产权分散是发展最大的阻碍之一,每个有权力的人都会先考虑自己,达不成一致,全局就不会有变化,错过发展的机会,形成一个僵局。中国选择了公权优先,扫清了产权的阻碍,先做大蛋糕,但究竟有没有更好的解决方案,能够平衡?
Finished watching the movie today after class since the homework given today is rather limited. We had a simulated Supreme Course discussion today during class. Yet unfortunately, I didn't get an opportunity to add good insights to it, for I personally stand on the side of Kilo and believe that a line should be drawn for "public use".
尽管the fifth amendment 并未改变,但这场案子对美国私**争产生了深远影响,很多州在类似问题上都会非常非常谨慎,几乎不会再轻易采取eminent domain。